Why are merchants hesitating to accept Amex credit cards?*

TY for the A2A.

I can think of at least three reasons why there might be question mark over acceptance of AmEx credit cards by Merchants:

  1. AmEx issues Merchant Accounts only to premium Merchants. If a Merchant is not premium, he won’t get an AmEx Merchant Account. In this case, the Merchant can’t accept an AmEx credit card even if he wants to.
  2. AmEx merchant fee (MDR) is higher than that of Visa / MasterCard / RuPay. In other words, a Merchant incurs a higher cost of accepting payments with an AmEx credit card than with a V / MC / RP credit card. If a Merchant is reasonably sure that customers in his target market will have V / MC / RP credit cards and that he won’t lose business by declining AmEx credit card, he can take a conscious decision not to apply for an AmEx Merchant Account. In this case, the Merchant can’t / won’t accept an AmEx credit card.
  3. Even if a Merchant has signed up for an AmEx Merchant Account and can accept AmEx credit card, he saves money if a customer pays with a V / MC / RP credit card instead of an AmEx credit card (because, as noted in #2 above, MDR for AmEx is higher than that for V / MC / RP). In this case, a Merchant will hesitate to accept an AmEx credit card in the hope that the customer will still make the purchase and pay for it with V / MC / RP credit card.

But that’s only a cost-conscious Merchant.

If a Merchant is a good businessman, he’d be more interested in increasing revenue than reducing cost. He’d be aware that an average AmEx credit cardholder spends more money as compared to an average V / MC / RP credit cardholder. Such a merchant will go out of his way to seek AmEx credit card holders and accept AmEx credit card even if they have V / MC / RP credit card.

In some markets, there’s a predominance of cost-conscious Merchants. In some others, there’s a predominance of revenue-conscious Merchants. Accordingly, extent of acceptance of AmEx credit cards is likely to vary from one market to another.