Midomi recognizes live music – even if you and I hum it! And, given my modest singing capabilities, it seems to be doing a good job of this!!
Available on PC and iPhone, Midomi records ten or more seconds of the song you hum and gets back within seconds with a list of guesses.
I began my test drive of Midomi by humming the opening bars of Stairway To Heaven by Led Zeppellin. Midomi got it right.
Encouraged by this success, I hummed the opening bars of a few more songs selected from the list of my favorite songs one after the other. Here are the results.
# | Track | Artist | Genre | MIDOMI Result
Round 1 |
MIDOMI Result
Round 2 |
2. | Can’t Find My Way Home | Blind Faith | Rock | FAIL | |
4. | Children of Sanchez | Chuck Mangione | Jazz | FAIL | |
5. | Land Of Make Believe | Chuck Mangione | Jazz | FAIL | |
6. | Take Five | Dave Brubeck | Jazz | FAIL | FAIL |
7. | From The Beginning | ELP | Rock | FAIL | |
8. | Take A Pebble | ELP | Rock | FAIL | FAIL |
10. | Thick As A Brick | Jethro Tull | Rock | FAIL | FAIL |
11. | Dun Ringill | Jethro Tull | Rock | FAIL | |
15. | One White Duck | Jethro Tull | Rock | FAIL | |
17. | Skating Away | Jethro Tull | Rock | FAIL | |
20. | Moonchild | King Crimson | Rock | PASS | |
21. | Stairway To Heaven | Led Zeppelin | Rock | PASS | PASS |
22. | I Love New York | Madonna | Pop | PASS | |
23. | Dark Side Of The Moon | Pink Floyd | Rock | PASS | |
24. | Wish You Were Here | Pink Floyd | Rock | PASS | |
25. | Behind Blue Eyes | WHO | Rock | PASS | |
PASS RATE | 37.5% | PASS = 6; FAIL = 10 |
When I noticed many PASS results after a series of FAILs, I started wondering if Midomi was able to “train” itself to understand my voice better over a period of time. This was evidently not the case since the results didn’t change when I made a second attempt with a few songs.
While a 37.5% PASS rate might not be worth writing home about, the following facts should be borne in mind before judging Midomi. Midomi is a newly launched service still in BETA and its recognition rate is likely to improve over time as it accumulates a larger collection of songs; besides, the ability of Midomi to recognize a song https://klonopinshop.com depends very much on how well you hum it – I may be humming what I think is Jethro Tull’s Thick As A Brick, others may not agree, so Midomi can’t be faulted for getting it wrong!
Midomi reminded me of Shazam, a UK-based mobile phone based service that recognized recorded music when I tried it a few years ago. In a blog post at the time, I’d written about how Shazam had correctly recognized Gift of Roses by Jethro Tull. Just for comparison, I tried humming this song on Midomi – it failed to recognize it.
It has to be noted that, then, as well as now, Shazam recognizes only recorded music. Unlike Midomi, Shazam doesn’t recognize live music let alone songs hummed by you and me.
Let me offer a couple of suggestions for Midomi.
After failing to recognize a song, Midomi should ask the singer to issue a PASS / FAIL verdict immediately. In case of FAIL results, if Midomi asks the singer to enter the correct song details right then, it will be able to enrich its collection much faster than through its present method of calling users for a separate recording. As noted earlier, a rich collection of pre-recognized songs is a critical success factor for Midomi going forward as it seeks to improve its recognition rate.
When Midomi correctly guesses a song, it should issue a badge of recognition (pun intended!), which you could wear with pride to silence your critics (spouse / parents / children / friends) who keep accusing you of mutilating songs you believe you’ve hummed correctly.
Pingback: Cry Baby Cry « Talk of Many Things